Claire cutting off her toe, while predictable from the moment the biology teacher mentioned regenerating limbs and pinky toes being unnecessary, freeeeaaaaked me out. GAH, I squinted my poors eyes so hard I think I pulled a muscle in my face.
Also, I fully expected Takezo Kensei to either run off or die and Hiro to take his place and become the historical figure of legend, so as soon as Kensei was struck by those arrows my entire group of friends figured we had been right all along and were prepared for Hiro to have to dispose of the body. When he suddenly healed, however, we all freaked out a little. Marvelous.