Honourable Justices,
This is a witness statement from Thel D'Ran of Lemuria, a very well respected NSer who frequents the #taijitu IRC channel, and other regional IRC channels as well.
On behalf of Govindia, I am writing to facilitate the proceedings in Taijitu. It is unusual for me to interfere in the politics of another region but I do this upon request.
Govindia is the victim of his own reputation, which — I truly believe — he hopes to ameliorate. Two significant factors stand in the way of his turning over a new leaf. The first is, of course, that same reputation. On that matter, there can be no dispute that it was earned by behavior and — perhaps — some degree of misunderstanding.
In my view, the second factor is a certain lack of forgiveness for and trust in Govindia that he does wish to make amends and begin a new era in the region(s) that have rejected him. As an outsider, I've a certain amount of luxury to make the claim that I believe him — but there it is.
I do not suggest that someone or group of persons have the role of "social guide" imposed upon them. Such an occupation can only be assumed and not imposed. Govindia will be, in fact, the chief of any such guide. The community's responsibility is to point out when he's "adding fuel to an existing fire" and ask him to stop. In addition, the community has every right to remind him (and other participants) when civility and mores are being abused. In essence, this is the part of the foundation of any social contract.
My player that made the request that I write this message is suffering a certain level of angst on this matter that's spawned by his confusion. If the Taijitu people do decide against him, please — at least — offer a full explanation.
Yours sincerely,
Thel D'Ran of Lemuria
As your honours have read, we can all clearly see that, as we have been saying, it is a big mis-understanding on both sides. We do accept that my client does have a bit of a reputation, as previous testimonies from Feudal Japan has already pointed out, but who of us doesn't for one thing or another? But he is a reformed character as this quote shows: "his turning over a new leaf" as he has tried to do before this whole mess started. Thel has known my client for quite some time and has understood the difficulties he has gone through, and has witnessed some of the treatment others have given him, especially where Meri has called my client a Hindu phony for not remembering specific aspects of his own religion. Not everyone is an expert on their own faith, for those who hold a belief in a spiritual entity.
We have another testimony we would like to present at this time from a respected and very active Taijituan citizen.
(2007-12-19 05:20:41) Osafune: So to start things off, please state your forum name and UN nation.
(2007-12-19 05:22:43) Delfos: My forum name is Delfos, my UN nation is New Delfos. I am a member of both Taijitu region, the forum.Taijitu.org, and I'm myself a qualified Citizen of Taijitu.
(2007-12-19 05:23:19) Govindia: Have you held any other positions in Taijitu?
(2007-12-19 05:23:37) Delfos: never
(2007-12-19 05:26:07) Osafune: Sorry about the pause. As I said, I'm currently at work.
(2007-12-19 05:26:37) Delfos: sure, no problem
(2007-12-19 05:27:05) Osafune: Delfos, can you please give a description of Govindia's character?
(2007-12-19 05:30:40) Delfos: Govinda as I know, I have never witnessed any offense or unusual behavior, Govinda is certainly qualified for Citizen and I've never seen any problem with his character that would provoke discrimination or even a trial.
(2007-12-19 05:31:17) Govindia: could you elaborate please?
(2007-12-19 05:33:46) Delfos: I have never wtinessed any offensive or unusual behavior, or any problem with Govindia's character that would provoke judgment against his membership, citizenship or his right to access the Role Play section.
(2007-12-19 05:35:14) Delfos: Govindia is a random person, and he's exactly as any other member of Taijitu
(2007-12-19 05:38:46) Osafune: "Discrimination"? Perhaps you could elaborate more on that as well.
(2007-12-19 05:40:18) Delfos: Well, I recall he was banned from Role Play section and from the forums without plausible justification or notice, among other discriminations like denying his right to post.
(2007-12-19 05:40:56) Osafune: This was before the trial, correct?
(2007-12-19 05:42:10) Delfos: That is correct, and even after the trial started I witnessed flaming and accusations outside the Court's topic about Govindia's trial.
(2007-12-19 05:44:00) Osafune: So how would you summarize everything so far? Gov's banning/restriction, the trial, etc...
(2007-12-19 05:47:37) Delfos: Well, my concern is that if they can do all this to Govindia without any justification or notice, they can do it to anybody, and I've witnessed other kinds of discrimination similar to what happened to Govindia and people getting banned or forced to leave Taijitu without any good justification, and without informing the Taijitu Community about the reason of such actions.
(2007-12-19 05:48:14) Govindia: Could you elaborate on this, and if possible, provide examples?
(2007-12-19 05:48:55) Delfos: I don't think I need to present examples, but names, let me recall them...the first that comes in mind beyond Govinda is Geradin
(2007-12-19 05:49:01) Delfos: *Govindia
(2007-12-19 05:56:51) Delfos: Well there is a name I cannot remember, that some members started to bully and forced him to leave. I want to present a recent case against Barakarin, trying to prevent the abuse, although messing with his account and achievements, such as post count, and also preventing him to defend himself and have his word by locking topics and the sort.
(2007-12-19 05:57:41) Delfos: This as being the worse cases, I could exhaustivly list several other cases, even involving myself
(2007-12-19 05:58:08) Govindia: Could you explain the case with yourself, and with Geradin, for the purposes of this testimony if we may ask?
(2007-12-19 06:02:39) Delfos: Well the purpose is to make sure the image of the forum administration and other administrative entities are seen. They ignore the rights of members, they do not defend their citizenship rights, and they also get involved in discrimination and the abuse of rights. I'm flamed allot or accused, well not so often latly, but the administration did nothing to prevent it from happening,
(2007-12-19 06:03:21) Delfos: also supported those involved in flaming accusations instead of defend each other's right or stopping the abuse of rights
(2007-12-19 06:04:40) Govindia: Why do you think they do that? Is Taijitu not supposed to be a friendly and respectful community to everyone who arrives?
(2007-12-19 06:08:50) Delfos: I think they established a solid hierarchy and favor some members over others, new members are welcome but whatever they defend is flamed, if their view of the world isn't the same as this group. I already confronted one of the Mafial-style lord about his power, he said he didn't know he had such power. They exerce their functions without knowing their duties or limits, without respt...
(2007-12-19 06:11:18) Delfos: without respecting membership/citizenship rights, and the other administrative entities normally do not do anything to stop or reserve any abuse.
I have the information that Myroria removed the ban on Gonvindia because it was inconstitutional, I must say that was quite rare interveinance of one administrator, which I must highlight positivly.
(2007-12-19 06:12:07) Govindia: Do you have any thoughts on the claims made by Prosecutor GMT that I am a security threat to Taijitu?
(2007-12-19 06:16:28) Delfos: I do, I don't see any threat to the security of Taijitu, as stated above, I see Govindia as a rightful member of the Taijitu community and no action from him suggests any breach of security of Taijitu. And I believe Govindia haven't committed anything against Taijitu, there should be no punishment.
(2007-12-19 06:18:23) Govindia: Do you have any thoughts on the character witness testimony that has been provided so far for this trial?
(2007-12-19 06:23:54) Delfos: I think some are misplaced and can't be judged without context, I also think some of the testimonies that didn't happened in the forum are doubtful or forged, but that's not for me to judge, and other from those, I can't formulate any thought on the content of such testimonies, I respect them as opinions, as most of them are, and not as conclusive evidence.
(2007-12-19 06:25:40) Govindia: You are planning to write a deposition still, yes?
(2007-12-19 06:27:32) Delfos: Yes, I've already wrote a deposition, basically saying everything I've said here.
(2007-12-19 06:27:51) Govindia: Would you still like to submit it ?
(2007-12-19 06:28:16) Delfos: Yes, where should I submit it?
(2007-12-19 06:28:54) Govindia: PM it to Osafune on the forum, and please e-mail me at gramabadran@gmail.com, as I cannot view PMs through the forum, nor send any.
(2007-12-19 06:32:22) Delfos: Are we done here?
(2007-12-19 06:33:20) Govindia: I have no further questions. Osafune may, I do not know. If you need to be elsewhere, I thank you for your time. If Osafune needs to ask you further questions, will you be willing to answer outside of this chat?
(2007-12-19 06:33:40) Delfos: Sure
(2007-12-19 06:34:14) Govindia: ok
(2007-12-19 06:34:35) Govindia: Thank you Delfos, for your time.
(2007-12-19 06:35:52) Delfos: No problem
First, it should be noted that as Delfos has said, has never held a leadership position in Taijitu. It is highly doubtful that he ever will attempt to. He has no reason to lie.
Most of his testimony virtually speaks for itself: He has not witnessed anything bad or harmful coming from the defendant. On the other hand, he has witnessed discrimination and abuse
against the defendant, which as Delfos says is nothing new.
The defense admitts that there may be a problem with this testimony; that being that he does not frequent IRC very often. Any event that may have went on in IRC may be unknown to him. This does
not change his testimony however; he still has not witnessed any abuses coming from Govindia and does not see him as a security threat. He HAS witnessed abuses
against Govindia.
It is still the position of the defense that most of the statements made by Govindia that ultimately arose to many of these charges are simply exaggerations and/or misunderstandings, a result partially from the frustration experienced by Govindia. Please notice PoD_Gunner's reaction to being called a "liar." What if people were continually calling you a liar, insulting you, and discriminating against you based on a "bad reputation" received in another region? Undoubtedly, any arguments between Govindia and any other citizen were inflamed by this.
Let me say something else: Govindia's fate in this trial should not relate directly to any crime committed in any other region. Such a thing would be like Canada trying me for a murder committed against an American citizen in the United States. That would not make much sense, would it? I'm not saying that the prosecution does not have a right to bring up such events that may have happened, but for the Court to take care when making their decision after seeing these unproven events presented towards them. Undoubtedly, a history of past events could hint towards the likelihood of someone committing the same crimes in Taijitu. It does
not prove that they will happen though.
When looking at the charges, harassment, and arguments between any two or more people, it is often worth looking into the history of all sides. Case-in-point: Meridianland. As previously stated, she has an extreme bias towards "fendas" and does not trust them. Since Govindia is a defender, there was obviously a lack of trust between the two, hence he did not want to reveal any information to her that can be used against him, as she is an active member of DEN. It should also be noted that Limi is a member of Lone Wolves United, another raider region .
What I'm trying to say is, not all of the charges you are trying to slap onto the defendant may have been caused by the defendant alone, but a myriad of circumstances.
Now, to address a few other things:
we believe that putting random statements of random players or regions in this equation are merely a waste of time
There was nothing "random" about any of the statements and testimonies we have presented so far. They are from delegates, leaders, and intelligence officers of regions that have experience with Govindia and know of his actions from TWP. We do not see how Ithania's testimony can possibly be considered "random" when she is a leader and citizen of one of the feeders you brought a testimony from, nor can the testimony of New Drakensburg Range, a long time NSer from England and very skilled at intelligence himself. Additionally, the members of Feudal Japan (now Tokugawa Japan) have also witnessed much of the treatment given to Govindia, and have seen how he acts in their region. Catlandatopia tried to discredit my client during the invasion, and failed. .
statements of famous Taijituans such as Korinn, Flemingovia or Meridianland or of our own root administration represent nothing in this case
As we pointed out, Meridianland's statement is biased. As things stand at the moment, we intend to focus on Korinn's and Flemingovia's testimony in our next statement.
Before closing this particular statement, there is one last thing I would like to say. Govindia did what he needed and took the oath to become citzen, but although he may be a restricted member of this forum, nowhere has anyone ever revoked his citizenship (or his ambassador position).